The Eye That Winked Without Permission

— Dr Jaydev Panchawagh  ·  MVD Surgery Centre, Pune

In This Essay

  1. A Twitch Called Hemifacial Spasm
  2. The Surgery Behind It: Microvascular Decompression
  3. Recovery After Microvascular Decompression

We spend our lives learning to read faces without being taught. A raised eyebrow. A flicker at the corner of the mouth. Long before Darwin wrote The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals and catalogued the muscles that betray us, humans already knew that the face speaks a language older than words. It is why an actor can hold a stage with nothing but stillness, and why a single twitch, in the wrong moment, can undo an entire sentence.

Most of us assume the face obeys us. It does — mostly. But there is a small, stubborn category of movement the face makes entirely on its own. A wink that isn’t a wink. An eye that closes when nothing has asked it to. For most people this passes in seconds, a minor mutiny, forgotten by lunch.

For a woman I will call Meera, it did not pass. It had been happening for six years.

A Twitch Called Hemifacial Spasm

A flicker at the corner of the eye, and the years it took to be taken seriously

Meera arrived at my clinic with her husband, a folder of prescriptions, and a habit she had developed without noticing — angling her face slightly away from whoever she was speaking to, so the left side, the side that moved, stayed out of view.

It had started small. A flutter near the eye, the kind everyone gets after too little sleep or too much coffee. Hers did not go away. Over months, it spread — from the eyelid down to the cheek, then to the corner of the mouth, until one side of her face was, in her own words, “doing its own thing.”

This is Hemifacial Spasm — involuntary, irregular contractions on one side of the face, caused not by nerves but by something touching them. Before we reached that word, Meera had been told it was stress. Then eye strain. Then, gently, that it might be anxiety, and had she considered speaking to someone.

None of this is unusual. Hemifacial Spasm is often misdiagnosed for years, mistaken for a tic, a psychological symptom, or the ordinary wear of a stressful life, because on the surface, a twitch looks like nothing at all. It takes a particular kind of attention to notice that the twitch is not behaving like an ordinary one — that it never announces itself with fatigue or resolves with rest, that it has a rhythm too regular to be voluntary.

Darwin argued that facial expression is not learned, but wired into us before birth, shared across cultures and species. He never imagined that in a few people, that same wiring could misfire — not from emotion, but from a blood vessel resting somewhere it shouldn’t.

The Surgery Behind It: Microvascular Decompression

Where the trouble actually begins — not in the face, but deep behind it

The facial nerve does not begin at the face. It begins at the brainstem, deep at the base of the skull, where it exits as a thin, pale thread no thicker than wet string.

In Hemifacial Spasm, a blood vessel — most often a small branch of the arteries supplying the brainstem — comes to rest directly against this nerve, at the exact point where it leaves the brain. This vessel does not sit still. It pulses, once with every heartbeat, thousands of times a day, brushing against the nerve with each beat.

Oliver Sacks would have recognised the shape of this story immediately — a case where the villain is not a disease in the usual sense, but a heartbeat in the wrong place. His book The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat is full of such cases. Each one shows a nervous system misfiring in some small, specific way. Each patient is stranger, and more human, than any textbook entry could make them. Hemifacial Spasm belongs on that shelf. Over months and years, the repeated, rhythmic contact of vessel against nerve irritates the nerve fibres until they begin to misfire, sending signals to the facial muscles that the brain never intended. The twitch a person sees in the mirror is, quite literally, an echo of their own pulse.

The operation to correct this — Microvascular Decompression — does one thing, and it does it precisely. Under an operating microscope, magnified many times over, we find the vessel and free it from the nerve. We lift it away from the point of contact and hold it there, permanently, with a small piece of Teflon — inert, soft, and biologically unreactive — placed between vessel and nerve like a doorstop that never rusts. With continuous nerve monitoring running throughout the operation, we can watch the nerve’s electrical behaviour change in real time, confirming the exact moment the irritation stops.

The compression that had been running quietly beneath her skin for six years is separated from the nerve in minutes. The spasm has one cause. Remove the cause, and the spasm has nothing left to answer to.

For most patients, the change is not gradual. It is immediate — on the table, or within the following days. The muscles that had been contracting to their own private rhythm simply stop.

Recovery After Microvascular Decompression

What it means to look straight into a camera and recognise every part of what looks back

Meera kept one photograph from before the surgery, tucked at the back of a drawer. It was from a wedding, taken three years into the spasm. She is standing at the edge of the frame, half turned, her chin dropped just enough to catch the light differently. Nobody else in the photograph is doing this. She remembers exactly why she did.

For six years, every photograph was a small negotiation: which angle, how much light, whether to laugh with her mouth closed.

Her husband had made calls, and visited other doctors, before they ever came to me — comparing notes on where this surgery was done well, weighing how much confidence he felt each time he spoke with a neurosurgeon. He told me about it only after Meera’s surgery, at a follow-up visit, almost in passing. Once they had decided whom to trust with her MVD, he said, they stopped thinking and simply followed instructions.

The muscles of the face are not like other muscles. We use them to signal, to warn, to invite. A stranger reads them in half a second and decides something about us before we speak. For six years, Meera’s face had been sending a signal she never intended — read by strangers as a wink, a smirk, something private and misplaced. After surgery, it stopped. In every photograph since, her face says only what she means it to say.

Names and identifying details have been changed to protect patient privacy. Shared with the patient’s consent.

Share This Post

About the Author

A neurosurgeon by training, a writer by compulsion — and a student of the human condition by necessity. These essays explore what science, surgery, literature, and life have in common: the fragile, extraordinary act of paying attention.

Table of Contents

Subscribe To Our Form

New essays, fortnightly. No noise — only ideas worth your time.

Continue Reading

The Eye That Winked Without Permission
01Sep

The Eye That Winked Without Permission

In This Essay A Twitch Called Hemifacial Spasm The Surgery Behind It: Microvascular Decompression Recovery…

The Mathematician Who Diagnosed Himself
04Aug

The Mathematician Who Diagnosed Himself

In this piece Diagnosing Trigeminal Neuralgia: A Patient Who Noticed What Doctors Missed Living With…

The Body Speaks First
31Jul

The Body Speaks First

I have spent much of my working life looking directly at the brain. Under the…